Robin vs. Cardinal: Songs, Habitat & Identification

Tori Rhodes
Written by
Last update:

Robin vs. Cardinal

Songs, Habitat & Identification

If you’re lucky enough to have a backyard, you’ve probably heard of robins. But are you surprised to learn there’s more than one kind of robin?

If you’re having trouble telling a bluebird from a robin, or a female cardinal from a female bluebird, we’re here to help with some tips on Robin vs. Cardinal identification.

Members of the thrush family, robins actually come in three colors:

  • Rufous – ruddy to reddish-brown
  • Hooded – ruddy with a black hood
  • Gray – grayish-brown to blackish-gray

All three types come in the same shape and size, and all have the same tufty crest on their heads. The females are paler and less colorful, so most people only see males.

Cardinals, also known as common cardinals, are found in the eastern part of the U.S., while bluebirds are found throughout the country, although they don’t live in Alaska. Cardinals are almost twice as big as robins, and while New World cardinals are found in many colors, Old World cardinals are mostly red.

Songs and sounds

The cardinal and the robin are two species of popular songbirds in the United States, and their songs are so distinctive that they are frequently used as symbols of different regions or states. During the night, their songs are quite similar, but during the day, they can be completely different.

During the day, the cardinal’s calls are louder and higher pitched than those of the robin. The robin’s song is raspier, sharper, and higher in pitch than that of the cardinal, with the cardinal’s being rougher and deeper in pitch. The cardinal’s song consists of clear whistles, whereas the robin’s is slower and more melodic.

The song of the cardinal is typically heard first, when the bird may be in the background or hard to see. It sings slightly above the canopy, and is not usually hidden. It may be more or less easily detected, depending on the environment and the presence or absence of calling or singing cardinals.

Size and shape

When it comes to size, both robins and cardinals are about the same size. Both measure between 10 and 12 inches in length from the tip of their bill to the end of their tail. The male robin is larger and weighs 6.5 grams more than the female while the male cardinal is larger than the female bird.

The robin and cardinal are two different species of songbirds that are commonly found in North America.

The robin is famous for its beautiful red breast and is a favorite among birdwatchers.

The cardinal is distinguished by its bright red coat and is known for its song.

Their habits and habitats are also different and this is one of the common ways to tell them apart. While the robin is usually found in suburban areas, the cardinals prefer wooded areas.

You can easily identify the differences between the robin and cardinal through their song. The cardinal’s song is called “cheer-cheer-cheer-cheer.”

The robin’s song is one of the most easily remembered songs in nature and is a common playground chant shared by school children around the world.

Color patterns and variations

In both species allow even scientists to have a hard time distinguishing between Robin and Cardinal.

But there are also some ways to distinguish them using their songs and habitat.

If you have ever watched a Cardinal, you would have noticed that it often wags its tail. It flaps its wings with a slight circular motion and wags its tail back and forth.

Robins on the other hand may look similar to Cardinals, but they are typically quieter and do not wag their tails.

Cardinals are also known to draw attention to themselves by moving around a lot. You will find them high up in the branches of the trees or shrubs and constantly moving around from branch to branch.

Robins are more hard to spot. They are usually quieter than their red counterparts. They blend into their surroundings and are very shy. They are more likely to be in the branches that are low down and also tend to sit motionless, unlike Cardinals.

The habitat is also a good indicator of the difference between Robins and Cardinals. Cardinals prefer sunny weather and can be seen in open woodland while Robins prefer a hide away in the deep woods.

Behavior

Cardinal and robin are both common and beautiful birds in central North America. They share the same colors, song and shape. Often people get them mixed up even professional birdwatchers themselves. I have been getting countless messages on this topic from my readers. So, to clear off all confusion and to know what is the difference between robin vs cardinal, I researched and found the answer.

During the spring season, male cardinals and robins search for a female mate. Both the birds build a cup shaped nest, however the shape and size of the nest differs in construction. The male birds are polygamous i.e. they mate with more than one female. The male cardinals have more colors in their body.

{Cardinal photo: By Gunnar Ries Amphibian & Reptile Conservation Alliance} and {Robin Photo: By Amanda Forest Blogger United States I am a Writer at The Avid Couponer}

Thr Eastern Robin (Turdus migratorius) is a small insectivorous songbird. It is a member of the thrush family. This bird is native to eastern North America, but can be found in western regions.

Habitat

The robin bird can be found on every continent except Antarctica.

The robin prefers to live in places with thick vegetation, especially trees. This is why you’ll find it in urban and suburban areas.

The robin can be easily recognized by its red breast and white belly.

The robin is one of the prey species of the American bald eagle. It’s only able to escape the eagle’s attacks by staying in close proximity to human settlements.

The robin’s nests are built on tree branches close to the ground. The original nest is not made by the bird. Instead, they add leaves to an existing nest, usually a bird’s abandoned nest. In the winter, the robin’s plumage becomes an olive brown color, which makes it hard to distinguish from the junco bird.

Field identification tips

For the robins and cardinals:

Robin and Cardinal are two of the most common birds we see during the winter.

Male cardinals can be identified by the bright red crest on their heads. Robin’s crest is dull brown and cannot be seen. The color of their breasts varies but most species of the robins have a red breast while the male cardinals have a black breast with red streaks.

Analyze the habitat and call to help you identify the species and the gender of the bird. Both robins and cardinals live in the same area but are very different in their food habits.

Both robins and cardinals will eat insects, fruit, and seeds. However, the cardinals prefer to eat seeds like sunflower while the robins, black-oil sunflower. The cardinals also eat caterpillars, flies, grasshoppers, spiders, and crickets.

Cardinals also love to eat suet, a commercial bird food made up of animal fat. Additionally, both robins and cardinals will eat blueberries, cherries, crabapples, and rose hips.

You can identify the robins by the quality of their songs. They are high-pitch and sweet. On the other hand, the vocalization of cardinals is scratchier.

How to tell the difference between a cardinal and a robin depends on how they sound and what they eat.

Conclusion

There might not be distinct characteristics distinguishing a Robin’s song from a Cardinal’s, but the detail in Robin’s songs are enjoyed by people, if not by other birds.

The Robin’s song is pretty nice for the human ear, but it is not very much appreciated by other birds. Some birds don’t appreciate the songs of others that could potentially attract predators. Birds sometimes might undergo harassment from other birds or even other animals.

Bird song is all about territory, but it depends on the species. The non-stop chirping of the Robin is somehow annoying for other animals. Meanwhile, the Red-winged Blackbird’s call sounds like it is warning the other birds in the area that the woods are theirs.